4-5" Bulk Bully Sticks - (50 Count) - Bully Sticks for Dogs - Long Lasting Dog Chews

Great value for the money! Everywhere else this quantity is way more expensive. Way better than other products for actually keeping tartar off your dogs teeth. I only wish they were more consistently sized. Some are very narrow and a bit shorter. However the majority are a good medium thickness and my dogs love them

Full odor and my dog adores it. She will independently start doing every trick she knows if I just mention getting one.

Opening the bag, the smell is awful. Smells rotten. They make it look like it comes in a large box, and the sticks look thick and long. They are NOT. Regarding the thickness of my male little finger, most are about that long. The cost over $40 bucks is crazy for these or any like them. I would rather not, but I guess it's back to the leather rolls. Two days later: I think these are cattle tails. Found one on the floor with a 2-inch bone. My Lab refused to eat it. There was raw flesh around the bone that was rotten!! She also choked on one that was 2 inches long. DANGER, DANGER, DANGER

Our puppies loved them. However, they are so chewable they don't last long at all. I'd say maybe 5 minutes for our big pup (85#) and only 15 for our 50#'er. They apparently taste quite good, and I didn't notice any smell at all. I wouldn't buy them again, simply because I wanted longer-lasting chews and not simple treats and these are too expensive for that.

I opened the package, handed the puppy one, and have so far enjoyed 90 minutes of uninterrupted bliss! He likes these way better than the last brand I bought. It took him 3 months to go through 10 of them, because he would just take them and hide them all over the house. I kept having to round them up. I don’t think I’m going to have that problem with these. I have a feeling he’s going to go through these a lot faster; which normally would be a bad sign, except anyone with an energetic puppy will understand why that is a good thing! They do have a smell, but not overpowering. I can only smell it if I bring it close to my nose. They are the perfect size and thickness for my 10 lb. Cavachon. It’s holding up pretty well with 90 minutes straight of aggressive chewing; he’s only about a third of the way through, and they are healthier than those other long-lasting chew treats.

My pup has been chewing on the same stick for 2hours! Shes a 4 month old border collie. Not sure how it would hold up if you have a lab, rottie, or larger breed, but I’m giving 5 stars simply bc she’s teething and they’re holding up WAY better than I thought!

These cow wieners small pretty bad. There’s pieces too small for my dog to chew. They must be killing calf’s to produce this product quicker. I’m talking pencil shape half the dang bag. Nothing but disappointment, poor doggy.

Pretty decent quality, but VERY thin. Not really suitable for medium to large dogs unless you have one of those chew holders, otherwise they may choke on them. My dog goes through them very quickly even with the chew holder I bought. Some in the bag are a small in every way. They are smelly in a good way: smelly enough for the dog, but the smell doesn't fill the room. My dog enjoys them a lot, but they only last like 30 seconds. I think they would be great for small dogs because they seem to taste great, but the size is just too small for dogs that are bigger than that.