Atkins Protein Cookie Peanut Butter, 4 Count

I’ve loved every atkins product that I’ve tried so far - but this one doesn’t quite tick the box. It’s still fairly tasty.. but i was expecting a sweeter peanut butter taste. I’ll definitely rather go for the chocolate chip next time.

I like the nutritional content but taste is just good, not great.

It leaves bad test

A+

These keto cookies are decent cookies. Probably one of the best available but I’m not a big fan of any flavor other thn the peanut butter. That being said, I didn’t throw the others out like I normally would if I can’t return something…,so I should say they are okay. All keto sweets have that slightly odd taste, so getting past that and you may find u like the chocolate chip and double chocolate. I will probably eat them when I have a sweet tooth and don’t have anything else but will only re- purchase the peanut butter. I actually look forward to the peanut butter ones.

Yes, they’re pricey but if you’re diabetic, they are a great snack that is low impact. I carry these in my car when I get caught out running errands that are taking too long and want something to eat. If I stop somewhere and say pick up a cuppa coffee and a cookie or a doughnut, if it cost me three times as much anyway and the Atkins cookie would be three times as healthy for me. Enough said!

I couldn’t stand the taste. My friend loved them hence the four star.

The smell. Like others have said, it's weirdly "chemical," like something you'd buy from the hardware store rather than a place that sells groceries. It's also reminiscent of wet, rotting wood, with a hint of boiled broccoli. Days after they were removed from the storage bin where I keep my shelf-stable foods, it still reeks, despite having been aired out. I kept one in my handbag as well to eat on the go, and it's the same story. This is the first time I ever encountered an ultra-processed food so tenaciously smelly. They're not soft, or crisp, or even chewy. They have a texture like clay that's been left to partially dry, and they taste like dust and glue. Not even a bit of peanut flavor that I can detect. I recommend that you DON'T buy these. Only if they were the absolute last food on earth would they be worth eating.